Hello everyone. Seeing that this whole thing became a meme war against my person, I would like to explain a little more about the situation of this website and I would like to propose some solutions.
Some time ago,
I put a topic in which I spoke about the messages they put some doujin artists in English, as a result of the closure of Megaupload. It doesn't cause any impact until a faggot put a "guide to send DMCA letters to Google" in his pixiv account, [
www.crunchyroll.com]
which was reported by Crunchyroll. Since that time, some artists, including Yuka Nakajima have been sending these messages reporting E-Hentai Galleries that contain scanlations to Google, removing them from the search list.
Also,
everyone knew the arrest of Korean people who worked in the scanlation scene and [
www.animenewsnetwork.com]
the recent arrest of the owner of a doujin-website which was profiting off of it. In this post I put four questions, which I quote:
QUOTE
1. Does this attitude will affect in a short-term the process of scanlation in the future?
2. Have you had any experience of any doujin circle or artist who asked to not distribute their work, whatever it is (including translations)?
3. What do you think that now the authors are putting warnings in English?
4. Will we end up in a witch hunt, like most notorious case of Linda Project vs. All the foreigners?
In one of them I put it if there will be a "witch hunt" against all scanlations. Ladies and gentlemen, it's happening. Now with people sending these letters to Google, there is a war between artists and scanlations. Just look at the Google Transparency Report and see how many galleries of this website have been removed.
What if it is legal what they are doing? According to U.S. law, although the parodies are classified as "fair use", these can be pursued by the copyright owners. In Japan it's the same. Remember the case of xxzero and his infamous Pokemon doujinshi? This is the same case.
I do not know if the recent action the circle ARCHIVES made is legal because, although they made a parody of the series Marimite, they cannot claim any right, unless it is an original work. The question is : will there be more actions like this? The answer: YES.
This is what I'm worried and, although many will say/are saying "you're a retard" or "you suck", is affecting all scanlations in general. As many have described here , it is unbelievable that an artist whose fame has been generating from this website, gives back to his/her international fandom commiting actions of dubious legality such as sending C&D letters of parodies of copyrighted work, instead of doing the exact opposite: to ask scanlations to translate their work, in order to earn more money. Money moves to industry.
That's not all: although I said in some parts that piracy of Japanese works comes from Japan itself, many of the doujinshi that are displayed in this site are replicated on Japanese websites. This has led to some accusations against foreigners saying "foreigners are pirates". Remember the infamous case of Linda Project. And that's not all. There have been cases of foreigners who have been in Comiket and have been rejected by many doujin circles. Yes, there are doujin circles who refused to sell to foreigners for the simple fact that they are pirates and they will upload their work on the Internet.
I'm gonna ask all the people who threw shit against me: what would you feel if you had a doujin artist you like, and then you go to Comiket in order to buy his work and the artist himself rejects you for being a "foreigner, pirate and thief"? Stop and think about that.
Because of this, I propose these solutions. Discard what I mentioned above here:
1. Hide all RAWs on this site and pin them for the fjords. Translations-only and everyone happy.
2. Auto-delete E-Hentai Galleries from Google in order to avoid any more DMCA letters.
3. Block all the website to the Japanese (the most extreme one).
Well, then, solutions are given. For my part, I'll see if I propose to doujin artists, especially the ones who are publishing in DLsite , to have their work translated with their permission and they can sell them on DLsite English . If you like this proposal, you're free to comment.
That's it. For my part I apologize if my previous comments were retarded. Another thing, if my IP is blocked (Firefox tells me that this Web isn't redirecting properly), unblock me since I have not broken any rule, AFAIK.
Thanks for reading this.
This post has been edited by deadFreak: Sep 8 2013, 06:38