QUOTE
QUOTE
This has no "sense", all of us did different sketches and all of them are rewarded... I guess... Well, I don't know.
Here's my point of view:
We made different sketches indeed, but...
There has to be one victor, so the client must choose the drawing he likes the most.
As for the reward, it's up to the client for giving reward for 1 or more drawings ^^
Such fussy ponies.
Anyways, hrm... If I have to pick favorites, It'd be
- BrainSuck's
- Muramasa's #2 pic
- Muramasa's #1 pic
- Muramasa's #3 pic
As for comments: (In order of appearances)
Muramasa1
Position of girl was kinda wrong for intents of the contest. Pretty sure I had attached a picture with the general idea of what I was looking for. In your pic, it looks like he's either sitting up, or she's lying on her back. Also, his face kinda creeps me out a little. And there's also something off with her hand. Hard to say what it is exactly though.
Muramasa2
This was almost right, except that I would've liked maybe a change on the angle a bit, mostly to highlight things like the breasts rubbing together and the like. Also, if you were looking at the actual challenge, you missed a rather important line: she was supposed to be clothed.
QUOTE
She would be... boobs out, torn pants
So: Blue Cargo pants (torn at the crotch) and a frilly black shirt with attached sleeves (pulled up to reveal her breasts) and a red diamond-shaped pendant on a gold chain around her neck. If it weren't for that, it'd be at #1.
Muramasa3
Not quite sure why you put in cowgirls :-X but Also, your sense of proportions seems to be off. That or the main girl is really, really large, or the two other girls are really small.
Also, one thing that bothered me about this (and #1) is that you seem to draw very angular heads, when I think ovals would be a bit better suited. And your necks are rather thick.
This was an outline I did of the heads in the third pic. The general line of the Face/front along the lines that should be their skull, so trying to cut out the hair lines.
(IMG:[
i.lulzimg.com]
http://i.lulzimg.com/109345ba00.png)
(In that third pic, the middle girl only had a neck visible on the left side. Otherwise, it looked like her head was actually coming directly out of her torso. The mark I put there was actually following her top line to where the neck should've been... :-X)
So I would have thought from just outline that this may have worked a bit better.
(IMG:[
i.lulzimg.com]
http://i.lulzimg.com/1d98df8e95.png)
Thoughts?
BrainSuck's
Good art, but I have some mild reservations on the main girl's expression, as well as your choice on using BlackAbbot as the secondary girl.
And for some minor nit-picking because I hold you in high regard:
- You forgot BlackAbbot's sunglasses.
- Hair highlights in the main model's hair and the outline on her body
- Pubic hair on a loli? MADNESS!
- aaaand you seem to have missed the nipples on BlackAbbot
Otherwise, nicely done :-3
I shall wire you all your credits shortly.
Art Battle :), Just a "game"...
Jan 29 2012, 01:59
