[X] My Assistant

I upload "To love Ru - eng - copleted"
https://e-hentai.org/g/229431/f22aa837f8/
(1996 pages at that moment)

Kir said:
Compilation of already uploaded volumes isn't allowed.

he probably told about "To-Love-Ru Vol.1 Uncensored (ENG)"
https://e-hentai.org/g/140197/b60c458009/
(only 205 pages, uplouded 1 year ago)

is he right??

yes- i delete whole galery (i dont like when somone uploud part of biger series)
no - i leave it ( how i can delet Kir's Petition to Expunge?)

Didn't you read the Expunge Guidelines?

1.2 A gallery that contains more than one manga tankoubon volume, doujinshi, Game CG set, magazine, language, or translation will be expunged.

Kir is correct, split it into each dojin as it was released and you can upload it, assuming it hasn't already been uploaded.

you wrote
"Compilation of already uploaded volumes isn't allowed."

i ask - shoud i delete 1800 pages just cos 1 year ago one guy uploud 200 and ended at that??

Kir is correct, split it into each dojin as it was released and you can upload it, assuming it hasn't already been uploaded.

i wrote
i dont like when somone uploud part of biger series
so i dont do that. completed or nothing...

thx for help
topic can be closed or deleyted.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Section 3 – Replacement
○ A newer higher-quality and clearly marked copy of this gallery has been uploaded.

3.1 Reasons for replacing a previously uploaded manga or doujinshi gallery include better image quality; replacing corrupted story pages; adding missing story pages; translator credits or translation notes; corrects the story page order of a badly mis-ordered manga or doujinshi; or moves an obvious Front Cover image to the beginning of a manga, doujinshi, or other story-type gallery.

i just forget write about that :/
3.1.1 All replacement galleries should have the reason for replacement in the Gallery Description or risk a duplication expunge

This post has been edited by Maxsiu88pl: Apr 23 2010, 20:45

Yes, according to the rules you delete your gallery, of course you can refuse if you want and we'll just delete it for you.

Edit: We aren't saying that you can't upload yours just because of the earlier upload, we're saying you have to split your 2000 page upload into separate chapters just like it was released in dojin form.

This post has been edited by bladejtr: Apr 23 2010, 21:13

1.2 A gallery that contains more than one manga tankoubon volume, doujinshi, Game CG set, magazine, language, or translation will be expunged.

Didn't you read the Expunge Guidelines?

The OP's gallery is not prohibited by the Guidelines. It's a collection of magazine chapters, which is actually encouraged under the same rules:

1.2.1 A gallery that contains multiple single chapters of a translated manga by the same translator is, however, preferred over a series of single chapter galleries, which will be expunged with each new compilation of chapters.

You could argue that the first 7 chapters should be removed, since it's the same translation as the volume 1 gallery, and the quality is inferior. However, there is nothing preventing the remaining chapters from being uploaded all in one gallery.

Didn't you read the Expunge Guidelines?

The OP's gallery is not prohibited by the Guidelines. It's a collection of magazine chapters, which is actually encouraged under the same rules:
You could argue that the first 7 chapters should be removed, since it's the same translation as the volume 1 gallery, and the quality is inferior. However, there is nothing preventing the remaining chapters from being uploaded all in one gallery.

Problem is it's not all from one release, it's supposed to be as acurrate as possible to the released form.
The rule you quoted:

multiple single chapters of a translated manga

This is not 1 translated manga, it was not released as a single manga, so it does not apply here.

Interesting.

Yes, as long as every chapter is from magazine, and not manga or tankoubon, it's encouraged under the guideline about putting a single continuous story from magazines into a single gallery, as it doesn't say how long the continuous story can be.

But if even one chapter isn't taken from magazine, then it should be expunged as compilation or that manga and something else, under rule 1.2, unless rule 1.2.1 applies.

Rule 1.2.1 mentioned by Sayo is only relevant if the gallery contains stories from the same volume. Obviously, it's not applying here, as no volume contains 101 chapters.

So the guidelines say it should be expunged, in my opinion.

EDIT: @Maksiu888pl: To upload this one in accordance to the guidelines, check which chapters went to which volumes. Then upload all chapters that went into first volume in one gallery, each chapter then went into second volume into another, and so on. If all earlier uploaded versions of some volume are of lower quality (or there isn't any), your gallery for that volume will stay, no matter if it was from magazine or tankoubon.

This post has been edited by Dlaglacz: Apr 23 2010, 22:51

The volumes are from different issues of the magazine which is specifically stated in ruloe 1.2, it says:

1.2 A gallery that contains more than one ...magazine... will be expunged.

They are from more than one magazine.

Rule 1.2.1 mentioned by Sayo is only relevant if the gallery contains stories from the same volume. Obviously, it's not applying here, as no volume contains 101 chapters.

It doesn't say that, though.

EDIT: @Maksiu888pl: To upload this one in accordance to the guidelines, check which chapters went to which volumes. Then upload all chapters that went into first volume in one gallery, each chapter then went into second volume into another, and so on. If all earlier uploaded versions of some volume are of lower quality (or there isn't any), your gallery for that volume will stay, no matter if it was from magazine or tankoubon.

You're assuming that this information is readily available.

While I agree that it would be neater if multiple magazine chapters were organised into "volumes", what do you do if you can't find out how many are in each volume?

The volumes are from different issues of the magazine which is specifically stated in ruloe 1.2, it says:

1.2 A gallery that contains more than one ...magazine... will be expunged.

They are from more than one magazine.

The gallery doesn't contain more than one magazine. It doesn't contain any magazines, only parts of them.

You're assuming that this information is readily available.

[en.wikipedia.org] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_To_Love-Ru_chapters
(IMG:[invalid] style_emoticons/default/tongue.gif)

See sayo, multiple volumes combined together, you can even tell which are which by the fact that there's cover pictures for each issue.

Hmm. Looks like you can tell which chapters belong to which volume. But not from the colour pics - those aren't tankobon covers.

i wrote that there was 200 page of "to love Ru" (non h category)
i wrote that, coz when i wrote "to love ru" in search, and it showed me only 1 vol.

when i wrote "toloveru" it showed me 2-5 vol...
just becose he wrote different tags i couldn't find more than this 1 vol.
that why i think, that made 1 big gallery is better than making 18 smaler (to love ru have acctually 18vol)


to bladejtr

1st

Specify an objective reason why you wish to expunge this gallery.


None / Withdraw Petition.

This gallery is a duplicate of equal or lower quality of an earlier posted, clearly marked gallery.

This gallery contains only worthless garbage with absolutely no redeeming qualities.

A newer higher-quality and clearly marked copy of this gallery has been uploaded.

This gallery contains illicit content, like child porn or anything else forbidden by the RoE.


I dont see option compilation in this. So if you could , withdraw your's petition. (from both my galleries)
Yes, it is compilation of 18 volmules, but that wasn't befor on hentai.org
so you can't say that is Duplicate

2nd

if you didn't uploud anything by yourself, stop messing with other people galleries without clear reason

This post has been edited by Maxsiu88pl: Apr 24 2010, 21:57

Compilations use already uploaded as the expunge option. The rules say no compilations of multiple tankobon volumes, if you upload the entire series as one gallery then obviously you have violated that. There is also a limit on the number of non-h galleries that you can upload. Uploading multiple volumes of a non-h manga in one gallery can also be seen as trying to work around this limit. People will call you on this as well and expunge your gallery.

DearS - complited - 1438 pages - 1 gallery
3,32K visits - 22K image accesses - 13 days since publisched - 1 complaint

Sekirei - ongoing - 1977 pages - 1 gallery
2.79K visits - 17.2K image accesses - 12 days since publisched - 1 complaint

both complaint from bladejtr ( just after i opening this topic)

if 6000 people doesn't complain, where is the problem??

This post has been edited by Maxsiu88pl: Apr 25 2010, 00:24

And did you read what Shadow Weaver wrote?
This is hentai site. Non hentai posting count have limits. Because of this, your galleries can be considered as cheating.

Compilations use already uploaded as the expunge option. The rules say no compilations of multiple tankobon volumes, if you upload the entire series as one gallery then obviously you have violated that. There is also a limit on the number of non-h galleries that you can upload. Uploading multiple volumes of a non-h manga in one gallery can also be seen as trying to work around this limit. People will call you on this as well and expunge your gallery.

Even though the gallery in question is not technically a compilation of multiple volumes, you make a good point about trying to evade the Non-H limit. I'm going to withdraw my previous objections.

...

2nd

if you didn't uploud anything by yourself, stop messing with other people galleries without clear reason

I have personally uploaded over 500 galleries. I just got sick of dealing with random expunges of my 2-3 year old galleries, so I deleted them all. If you're curious you can find them still here: https://e-hentai.org/?f_doujinshi=1&f...mp;f_sfdd=favdc

Oh look, more and more people are agreeing with me on the 2 galleries you had left.

This post has been edited by bladejtr: Apr 25 2010, 08:59

yeah right... that was the smartest
"+12 Duplicate on 2010-04-24 22:28 by Rikis
Details: Sekirei"


and again hao stiupid that opton is...
6000 people who like that

6 people (the same for both galleries) wanted to tease me
there's nothing like followers who do what you (look at names and time)

"DearS - manga - eng - Completed - ch1-47

Expunge Log
+18 Duplicate on 2010-04-25 07:23 by Rei-Tenshi
Details: compilation
+14 Duplicate on 2010-04-25 07:17 by MasakiLHW
Details: comp
+19 Duplicate on 2010-04-25 06:53 by pop9
Details: comp
+26 Duplicate on 2010-04-25 06:38 by Kir
Details: compilation
+12 Duplicate on 2010-04-24 22:28 by Rikis
Details: compilation
+22 Duplicate on 2010-04-23 19:15 by bladejtr
Details: compilation
"
"
Sekirei - manga - eng - ongoing - ch 1-98 - non hentai - part 1

Expunge Log
+18 Duplicate on 2010-04-25 07:24 by Rei-Tenshi
Details: compilation
+14 Duplicate on 2010-04-25 07:17 by MasakiLHW
Details: comp
+19 Duplicate on 2010-04-25 06:53 by pop9
Details: comp
+26 Duplicate on 2010-04-25 06:38 by Kir
Details: compilation
+12 Duplicate on 2010-04-24 22:28 by Rikis
Details: Sekirei
+22 Duplicate on 2010-04-23 19:14 by bladejtr
Details: compilation
"

This post has been edited by Maxsiu88pl: Apr 25 2010, 10:14